Saturday, February 1, 2020
BOOK REVIEW: “Standing on the Walls of Time”
Cover, Standing on the Walls of Time:
Ancient Art of Utah's Cliffs and Canyons,
by Kevin T. Jones.
I have
never understood why so many self-appointed “experts” in rock art make such a
big deal about "it is not really
art" or, "those people
never even had a word for art." Why would you choose to devote yourself
to a subject and then begin by denigrating it? These people are usually brand
new to the field of rock art and almost invariably totally ignorant of the disciplines
of Art History. As someone with a background in Art History my answer to them
has always been "of course it is
art. It is art because I say so."
Art Historians have always chosen what they wish to study based on the
creativity of the material and their curiosity about the culture, and the
designation of art goes with their attention to the subject. So-called "Primitive Art" has been a subset of
the field of Art History for at least a century and a half.
Barrier Canyon style,
"the Perfect Panel",
Fig. 3.1, p. 26.,
Photograph Layne Miller.
Now, I have
an official and legal backup for my position because the legislature of the
State of Utah in 2017 passed SB2017-171 declaring Utah's rock art as Official Art
of the State of Utah, signed into law by the Governor of Utah on March 22, 2017.
Earlier in
2017 the Utah Legislature had named Robert Smithson’s Spiral Jetty (a work of
landscape art that I have always admired) as the official Utah State Work of
Art. As a former Utah State Archaeologist, Kevin T. Jones was not supposed to
consider rock art as anything but an artifact, without meaning, and certainly
not ART. Yet the news about the Spiral Jetty bothered him. How could Utah, a state
named after its indigenous peoples, ignore the amazing petroglyphs and
pictographs found in such abundance all over the State, left by those
indigenous people? Jones came to the conclusion that this was actually art,
and, as such, deserved at least equal billing with a modern construction done
by someone from outside the State. His subsequent efforts led to the passage of
Utah’s SB2017-171.
Figure with yucca, Barrier Canyon
style or Basketmaker, Fig. 2.5, p. 14.,
Photograph Layne Miller.
That leads
me to this review of his book Standing on
the Walls of Time: Ancient Art of Utah's Cliffs and Canyons, by Kevin T.
Jones, with photographs by Layne Miller, University of Utah Press, 2019, 152
pp., 153 color photos, 1 map, $19.95 (paper).
This is not
a text book - it contains very little factual or scientific information about
the prehistoric peoples who lived in Utah and created the rock art. This is not
a coffee table book, although it is filled with magnificent photographs by
Layne Miller. This book is an art appreciation book although Jones himself had
never thought of it that way. Indeed, he seemed surprised when I referred to it
as such when discussing it with him. It is a paean to the creative imagination
and sophisticated cultures of the people who created the pictographs and
petroglyphs that fill its pages.
Fremont, "The family panel",
Nine-Mile Canyon, Fig. 7.8, p. 74,
Photograph Layne Miller.
In chapter
one (on page 3) he writes "Some view
the art of early cultures as code for something knowable through induction,
such as representing maps, stories, calendars, astronomical markers, even
validation of Western religious teachings. This book represents a departure
from nearly all of these approaches. I am not going to try to interpret the
artist's meanings or symbols. In fact, I am strongly opposed to that approach.
I do not try to match or categorize symbols in an attempt to advance culture
history studies. I advocate for a much simpler, more human approach - to view
the work of ancient artists purely as art. Let it reach you on more of an
emotional, as opposed to intellectual level." Jones' inner journey from the traditional
archaeologist's position that "rock
art is nothing but artifacts, we will never understand it" to his
present belief must have been in equal parts uncomfortable and exciting for a
professional archaeologist. His 180ᵒ reversal from the predominant "official" position of North
American archaeologists of 20 -30 years ago to his present advocacy must have
been a remarkable adventure.
Kevin’s
conclusions on how we should relate to rock art have also taken a
non-traditional turn. In chapter fourteen (on page 140) he wrote - "While some take pride in keeping site
locations secret and only sharing them with "trusted" associates,
this does nothing to protect sites. Hoarding special knowledge may be good for
your status among friends, but it is self-serving and not beneficial to the
resource.
Sharing your love and appreciation
of ancient art is beneficial, as it enables better management and protection of
sites and brings more allies into the ranks of caretakers and stewards. Take
photographs, share them with your friends. Post them on social media without
revealing exact locations. Enjoy and love these gifts from those who lived
before us, and those who live after us, those who live a hundred years from
now, will likewise be able to enjoy and love them."
Fremont, "The Wolf Man",
Nine-Mile Canyon, Fig. 9.6, p. 94,
Photograph Layne Miller.
This volume
is a once-in-a-lifetime book. There are many good, even great, rock art books
on today’s market. I have reviewed a number of them here on RockArtBlog over
the years. But I have seen nothing like this book before. Do yourself a favor,
read “Standing on the Walls of Time”
by Kevin T. Jones.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment