Saturday, August 1, 2020

A POSSIBLE COMET RECORDED AT CABORCA, SONORA, MEXICO:


Petroglyph at Caborca, Sonora, Mexico.
Photograph Margaret Berrier, 1993.

Comets have always fascinated humans whether seen as good omens or evil portents. As I am writing this Comet Neowise (C/2020 F3) is overhead in the evening sky under the Big Dipper. A sight like this would have been even more impressive to people in a dark sky with no light pollution centuries ago. I recently received a picture from Margaret Berrier of a petroglyph panel near Caborca, in Sonora, Mexico, which appears to include a possible comet image.

Comet Neowise, Northern Arizona, July 18, 2020, from Flagstaff, AZ. Photograph Austin Young, online image.

Margaret is an independent rock art researcher who lives in New Mexico and took the photograph in 1993. Indeed, the panel can be interpreted to show a comet passing a crescent moon. The rock art is attributed to the Trinchera Tradition, which is dated to between 750 and 1450 CE, with a range extending from the Gulf of California into northern Sonora. (Wikipedia) These people certainly were stone workers. Their culture is named Trinchera (trenches) after the rock terraces that they created up hillsides, believed to be used for residential areas as well as possibly agriculture (although why the name is not Terrazza for terraces escapes me).

Trincheras at Cerro De Trincheras, online photograph from www.swvirtualmuseum.com.

"Contemporaneous with the Hohokam of the river valleys of southern and central Arizona were pottery-making cultures adapted to the desert province of the Papagueria of southern Arizona and northern Sonora. A distinctive complex known as the Trincheras culture was centered in the Magdalena and Altar valleys of northern Sonora, the name Trincheras being derived from the terraced hillsides or 'fortified' hills that are the most obvious architectural feature of these sites. These desert groups probably had roots in the Cochise and their cultural systems reflect different adaptive responses to the local environment. Subsistence in the dry Papagueria was based primarily on hunting and gathering." (Schaafsma 1980:99)

What relationships existed between Trincheras and Hohokam has been argued at length. Some consider Trincheras to be a manifestation of a "Desert Hohokam" complex while others deny any relationship at all. (Schaafsma 1980:100)

"The last view, however, is not borne out by the rock art. Shared petroglyph elements and stylistic traits throughout the entire area suggest that all the various populations, including the Hohokam, were in communication and participated in shared ideas. One of the prime mechanisms for this interaction may have been the shell trade from the Gulf of California. The Trinchera people themselves were the major suppliers of shell for the more northerly Hohokam and such a trade would have been an important means of facilitating direct communication with the north." (Schaafsma 1980:101)

As we now know there was considerable south-north contact between the cultures of the desert southwest, especially commercial contact and trade.

"The rock art of the Trincheras culture is less well known than that of the Hohokam. Nevertheless, petroglyphs are fairly common in the Magdalena-Altar riverine region. - - -Design elements consist of anthropomorphic, zoomorphic, and geometric figures in the Hohokam style. On Cerro las Trincheras, the first of these sites to be so named, are representations of quadrupeds, spirals, and other abstract designs, both curvilinear and rectilinear. From Caborca and a Trincheras site near La Nariz east of Sonora, Lumholtz (1912) illustrates further Hohokam-like designs - again spirals, a set of frets, lizards with  the typical central bulge, and a pattern of interlocking scrolls." (Schaafsma 1980:101)

"Differences between the Trincheras petroglyphs of Sonora and the Arizona Hohokam lie primarily in the degree of refinement in design and in technical matters, the Sonoran figures generally excelling in these aspects." (Schaafsma 1980:101)


Petroglyph at Caborca, Sonora, Mexico. Photograph Margaret Berrier, 1993.

This panel, which includes a possible comet image, also shows an orb which can be interpreted as a crescent moon (a comet would be seen, of course, in the night sky). All-in-all this seems a fairly reasonable assumption. Which comet would be represented, on the other hand, is probably impossible to determine. During the time span of the Trinchera complex there are historical records from other cultures of comets appearing and we can guess it was possibly one of those.

For instance in 837 AD, Halley's comet approached as close as 3.2 million miles to the Earth, its tail stretching some 60 degrees across the sky (this is 1/3 of the distance across the sky from horizon to horizon). This appearance was recorded in annals in China, Japan, Germany, and the Byzantine empire. Halley's also was recorded subsequently in 989, 1066, 1145, 1222, and 1301 AD. (Wikipedia)

The 1066 AD appearance of Halley's comet is probably the source of the painted comet image above the Peñasco Blanco trail in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico (Faris 2010) and as the most impressive on record is probably a logical candidate for the inspiration of this Trinchera petroglyph.


NOTES: Thank you to Margaret Berrier for sharing this interesting photograph as well as permission to use it.

Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.

REFERENCES:

 

Faris, Peter

2010   Halley's Comet Pictured in Chaco Canyon, November 20, 2010, https://rockartblog.blogspot.com/search/label/Halley%27s%20comet.

Schaafsma, Polly

1980   Indian Rock Art of the Southwest, School of American Research, Santa Fe, pp. 99-101.

Wikipedia,

History of Sonora, https://en.wikipedia.org

Halley's Comet, https://en.wikipedia.org


Sunday, July 26, 2020

THIS ROCK ART IN WALES MAY BE BRITAIN'S EARLIEST:



Gower Cave, in Wales, Britain.
Photograph: Bradshaw Foundation.

A petroglyph discovered in a cave in Wales by an archaeologist from the University of Bristol has been proposed as the earliest petroglyph in Britain. "The chance finding by Dr. George Nash from the University's Department of Archaeology and Anthropology, of a reindeer wall engraving in a South Wales cave could be Britain's oldest example of rock art dating more than 14,000 years ago. Dr. Nash discovered the faint scratchings of a speared reindeer while visiting the Gower Peninsula Caves near Swansea in September 2010. The drawing is believed to have been carved by a hunter-gatherer artist in the Ice Age." (Heritage Daily 2011) 

"In the 1950s, Cambridge University undertook an excavation there and found 300-400 pieces of flint and dated the occupation of the cave to between 12,000-14,000 BC. This drawing appears to have (been) engraved by an artist using his or her right hand as the panel on which it is carved is located in a very tight niche." (Heritage Daily 2011)


Gower Cave panel, Wales, Britain.
Photograph Bradshaw Foundation.

This image was previously cited as an example of Handedness in rock art (see Handedness in Rock Art published in RockArtBlog on June 6, 2020) because its location and orientation suggest that it had to have been created by a right-handed artist.

Gower Cave, Wales, Britain.
Image digitally highlighted.
Internet photo - Public domain.

"Until the 13th century, wild herds of reindeer could be found roaming freely in Scotland until the species was hunted to extinction. Reindeer became extinct in the UK about 800 years ago because of hunting, the vikings are thought to have hunted them - but also due to climate change." (McNeish 2019)

Gower Cave, Wales, Britain.
Drawing of panel. Internet
photo - Public domain.

"The discovery of a cervid, probably an engraved reindeer, was made on a vertical panel inside a discrete niche northeast of the main gallery. This almost hidden engraving is the first possible evidence of Pleistocene rock art in Wales and only the second discovery of rock art in Britain of this period. Along with this figure are a number of other engravings awaiting evaluation and a possible area of applied hematite that may be contemporary with the reindeer engraving. If this is the case this will be the first evidence of painted rock art in the British Isles." (Nash 2011: 151)

The important message to be taken from this is to never give up on finding more rock art. This cave had been visited by archaeologists and students since the 1950s, yet this one image was still waiting, undiscovered, for Dr. Nash on this particular day. Who knows what else will still turn up?


NOTE: Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.

REFERENCES:

McNeish, Cameron  -  2019 British Reindeer guide: species facts and where to see in the UK, Countryfile, Nov. 11, 2019, https://www.countryfile.com/wildlife/12-things-you-never-knew-about-reindeer/

http://www.bradshawfoundation.com/british_isles_prehistory_archive/gower_peninsula_south_wales/images.

Heritage Daily -  2011 Archaeologist's Chance Discovery May Be Britain's Earliest Example of Rock Art, https://www.heritagedaily.com/2011/08/archaeologist%e2%80%99s-chance-discovery-may-be-britains-earliest-example-of-rock-art/7067

Nash, George, Peter Van Calsteren, and Louise Thomas  -  2011 Marks of Sanctity? Discovery of Rock Art on the Gower Peninsula, South Wales, Time and Mind: The Journal of Archaeology, Consciousness and Culture, Vol. 4, Issue 2, July 2011, pp. 149-154


Saturday, July 11, 2020

CORPORATE GREED AND VANDALISM - RIO TINTO CORPORATION BLOWS UP SACRED PILBARA SITES:

 This cave in the Juukan Gorge, dubbed Juukan 2, was destroyed in a mining blast. Photograph: The Puutu Kunti Kurrama and Pinikura Aboriginal Corporation.


In a stunning example of corporate greed and total lack of sensitivity, not only to ethnic sensibility, but to scientific value, the Rio Tinto Mining Corporation blew up rock shelters bearing evidence of 46,000 years of occupation in Australia's Pilbara region.

"A sacred site in Western Australia that showed 46,000 years of continual occupation and provided a 4,000-year-old genetic link to the present-day traditional owners has been destroyed in the expansion of an iron ore mine. The cave in Juukan Gorge i the Hammersley Ranges, about 60km from Mt. Tom Price, is one of the oldest in the western Pilbara region and the only inland site in Australia to show signs of continual human occupation through the last Ice Age. it was blasted along with another sacred site on Sunday. Mining company Rio Tinto received ministerial consent to destroy or damage the site in 2013 under WA's outdated Aboriginal heritage laws, which were drafted in 1972 to favour mining proponents. One year after consent was granted, an archaeological dig intended to salvage whatever could be saved discovered the site was more than twice as old as previously thought and rich in artefacts, including sacred objects." (Wahlquist 2020)

Juukan 2, after the blast. Photograph: The Puutu Kunti Kurrama and Pinikura Aboriginal Corporation.


According to current understanding "The Aboriginal population of the Pilbara considerably predates, by 30-40,000 years, the European colonisation of the region. Archaeological evidence indicates that people were living in the Pilbara even during the harsh climatic conditions of the Last Glacial Maximum. The early history of the first peoples is held within an oral tradtition, archaeological evidence, and petroglyphs. Near the town of Dampier is a peninsula known as Murujuga, which contains a large collection of world heritage listed petroglyphs, dating back thousands of years. Rock art in the Pilbara appears to have been primarily etched into the hard rock surfaces, compared to predominantly paintings on the softer sandstone of the Kimberley. This does not preclude that painting was and is not performed in the Pilbara. In 2006, it was estimated that 15% of the population of the Pilbara was of indigenous background, approximately 6,000 people." (Wikipedia)

While I have been unable to determine whether any Aboriginal rock art was actually destroyed along with the caves, it is hard to believe that there were no graphic images or markings remaining from 46,000 years of occupation. In any case they were important archeological sites as well as important examples of cultural heritage, and their destruction illustrates the mindless ignorance of corporate profiteering. 


REFERENCES:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilbara


Wahlquist, Calla

2020 Rio Tinto Blasts 46,000-year-old Aboriginal Site to Expand Iron Ore Mine, May 25, 2020, the Guardian, Manchester, England.


Friday, July 10, 2020

A SUPPOSED STONE MAP PETROGLYPH IN MEXICO:


Photo  Rafael Platas Ruiz, INAH, Colima, Mexico.

One claim that occurs frequently in rock art interpretation is that a particular design represents a map. In the past I have argued that this is unlikely in North America for a few reasons.

1. These were oral societies who, before contact, passed information on by word of mouth, not writing.

2. They did not have any use for a map. They already knew every square inch of their territory and where every resource could be found, as well as we know our back yards and the local grocery store. These are tribal people living within a territory that they know as well as the back of their hand.

3. A permanent map carved into the rock could be of help to possibly hostile outside groups and raiders.

 

Even though many of my friends and co-researchers believe claims that many North American examples do represent maps (how many map rocks have you seen?) I am still very skeptical about claims for maps in North American rock art.

I have visited many sites with rock art panels that local "experts" identify as a map, and I have yet to find one in North America that I can accept, but, there are situations and places where rock art maps might actually be found.


Photo INAH, Colima, Mexico.

Now we have a report out of Mexico of a carved boulder that has been identified as a map. "Archaeologists from the Instituto Nacional de Antropologia e Historis (INAH) have announced the discovery of a stone map that dates from between 200 BC and AD 200 in Colima, Mexico. The map represents the territory of Pre-Columbian natives living around Colima (evident by small circular features that shows the position of ancient settlements), that was carved on a basalt volcanic rock deposited in situ after being thrown from an ancient eruption at the Colima volcano some 14 km away. The stone, measures 1.7 metres in height and sits on an axis of approximately 20° to the northeast and is orientated towards the volcano." (heritagedaily.com 2020) In other words this large lava boulder is a volcanic bomb that was thrown 8 miles from the volcano to its present position.

"In a statement INAH said that the stone is oriented with its main surface facing the Fuego de Colima volcano 'and it has cavities that could represent villages, as well as lines associated with waterways and geographical features'." (LaPrensa 2020) According to the head of INAH, Julio Ignacio Martinez de la Rosa, "the identification of the map is based on a study of the designs and patterns as well as a comparison to similar petroglyphs found in the region. The stone has carved hollows that represent villages, as well as lines that can be association with natural orographic and hydrological features. Inspection of the map has been conducted by Archaeologist Rafael Platas Ruiz who has found that some features also correspond with the geographical landscape of the southern slope of the Colima volcano, with ravines and rivers clearly apparent." (Heritagedaily 2020) With the boulder located 8 miles (14km) from the volcano, and with details of the volcano's southern slope included in its carving, the map must depict an area more than 8 miles across in one dimension, quite a large endeavor.


Photo Rafael Platas Ruiz, INAH, Colima, Mexico. 

"Colima is a small state of Western Mexico on the central Pacific coast, and includes the four oceanic Revillagigedo Islands. Mainland Colima borders with the states of Jalisco and Michoacan." (Wikipedia)

"Archaeologist Rafael Platas Ruiz, the official in charge of examining cultural heritage items, said that the stone features 'at least three carving techniques - polishing, chipping and sanding - which were used to represent the surrounding landscape in various ways'." (La Prensa 2020)

Ruiz stated "the stone is not associated with the Chanal phase. Its designs and workmanship techniques have a greater relationship with the . . . period from 200 BC to 200 AD - that is, the period between the Late Preclassical and Early Classic periods". (La Prensa 2020)

These dates would lakely place it in the Los Ortices era which began around 1500 BCE, and preceded the Comala phase from 100 to 600 CE which featured the burnished red pottery figures of people and fattened dogs known so well today. (Wikipedia)

 

Fig. 7a, p. 66, page from Codex Boturini, departure from Aztlan on the date '1 flint'. From Helmke, Nielsen, and Guzman.

And again, "Archaeologists determined that the context dating doesn't correspond with the Chanal or Postclassic Colimense phase (1000-1500 AD) and instead (has) drawn comparisons to early tombs from the Late Preclassic and Early Classic periods  between 200 BC and AD 200." (Heritagedaily)


Fig.4, p. 62, First page of Codex Zolotl, map of Valley of Mexico. From Helmke, Nielsen, and Guzman.

Fig. 3, p. 60, Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca, map of Quauhtunchan city state in Puebla, Mexico. From Helmke, Nielsen, and Guzman.

In this instance I am much more inclined to accept the interpretation of the petroglyphic design as a map. These were not hunting/gathering cultures surviving within and off of the landscape, they were authoritarian cultures with political boundaries, depending on resources located within their territories, collection of taxes from their populations, and profiting from trade (and sometimes conflict) with other polities. It makes much more sense to me that they would have use for a map for planning purposes and keeping accurate records. Indeed, we know from surviving codices and murals that many of the civilizations of Mexico had cartographic traditions.

 

 

Although these Mexican examples are, in fact, illustrating an event while showing details of where it occurred, these details just as surely constitute a map record as our much more general mapping tradition.

Previous postings on the subject of maps on RockArtBlog include:

1. April 18, 2009, Are There Maps In Native American Rock Art?

2. August 17, 2013, Maps in Rock Art - 3-D Carved Maps.

3. March 12, 2016, Maps In Rock Art - Revisited.

4. March 9, 2019, Are These Ute Wooden Maps? - or Apophenia/Pareidolia/Mimetoliths/Manuports.

NOTE: Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.

REFERENCES:

Helmke, Christopher, Jesper Nielsen Angel Ivan Rivera Guzman

2019 The Origins and Development of the Cartographic Tradition in the Central Mexican Highlands, Contributions in New World Archaeology, Vol. 12, Polish Academy of Arts and Sciences and Jagiellonian University Institute of Archaeology, Krakow, Poland.

https://www.heritagedaily.com/2020/06/archaeologists-discover-2000-year-old-stone-map-on-volcanic-rock/133727

https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Colima

Online News Editor

2020 Mexico Registers Petrogyph Used as Stone-Map Some 2,000 Years Ago, June 14, 2020, La Prensa, https://www.laprensalatina.com/mexico-registers-petroglyph-used-as-stone-map-some-2000-years-ago/


Saturday, July 4, 2020

ROCK ART DAMAGED BY FIRE IN QUEENSLAND, AUSTRALIA:

Australia's Baloon Cave rock art site viewing platform before the fire. Internet photo: public domain.


A popular Australian rock art tourist destination, Baloon Cave in Carnarvon Gorge, Queensland, Australia, was destroyed by fire in late 2018. An article by Paul Taçon for the Bradshaw Foundation's Rock Art Network outlines how efforts to protect this rock art destination actually led to its destruction.


"Aboriginal Australians maintain powerful connections to rock art sites and argue that these heritage places are a part of living culture. Moreover, most indigenous Australians desire to share their heritage with the wider world and over 100 rock art sites are open for guided or unescorted visitation. But infrastructure and resources vary widely and rarely do sites have conservation and/or management plans." (Taçon 2019)

Baloon Cave before and after the fire. Internet photo: public domain.

One site that allows public visitation is Baloon Cave, "located in Carnarvon Gorge, central Queensland, Australia. It was one of the four rock art sites open to the public for visitation in Carnarvon Gorge and the closest to the visitor area and ranger station. It is known for its sets of stenciled hands and a series of hafted stone axe stencils. Initially access to Baloon Cave was via a stone and soil walking track, with low handrails separating visitors from the art panels. However, some vandalism occurred with lines and letters scratched over and into stencils.

To facilitate better access and to better protect the rock art a large viewing platform and walkway was installed at Baloon Cave in 2014. REPLAS Enduroplank recycled plastic products were used with composite fibre structural components. On the REPLAS website the Enduroplank is promoted as a low maintenance endurable material suitable for Baloon Cave." (Taçon 2019)

Baloon Cave rock art panel before the fire. Internet photo: public domain.


"ABC Australia reports that ancient rock art at eastern Australia's Carnarvon National Park was destroyed in 2018 when a walkway made of recycled plastic exploded during a brushfire. 'Unfortunately, that's sort of like solidified petroleum, and if you have a hot fire underneath it, it melts and then it just explodes into a ball of flame and that's exactly what happened,' said Paul Taçon of Griffith University. Pieces of rock sloughed off Baloon Cave's walls, along with the artwork which included ancient handprints and more recent  images. Dale Harding, a member of the Baloon Cave working group, called the lost artwork a link between generations of Bidjara, Ghungalu, and Garingbal people." (Wikipedia)

This product is apparently touted as fire retardant but experience is proving otherwise. Brushfires reportedly also ignited Enduroplank structures at two other locations in addition to Baloon Cave.

Baloon Cave rock art panel after the fire. Internet photo: public domain.

The rock art at Baloon Cave was seriously impacted.

"Damage to the main panel consists of exfoliation to the left, right and above right, cracking at the upper right, and a coating of soot over most of the stencilled hands and all of the hafted axe stencils. As one approaches the panel, it first appears it is completely blackened but closer inspection and photography with the light at the right angle reveals the stencils underneath." (Taçon 2019)

"Damage to the rare hafted stone axe stencils is pronounced as not only have they been blackened but also where two of them are located the rock has both cracked and exfoliated. The cracked portion at the left looks as if it could easily collapse. It may be possible to remove the soot and to consolidate the panel but this needs further investigation and assessment. Some soot has washed away in recent heavy rain. There is a risk that the rock above the major new crack could sheer off and fall to the ground, taking portions of the stencils with it." (Taçon 2019)

Although he acknowledged that non-flammable construction would possibly be more expensive "Taçon suggested that only steel, or concrete and steel, but used to construct walkways at Australia's cultural heritage sites." (Wikipedia)


This should be a lesson to us all concerned with the protection of rock art.


NOTE: Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.

REFERENCES:

https://www.archaeology.org/news?page=1


Taçon, Paul

2019 The Aftermath of Fire Damage to Important Rock Art at the Baloon Cave Tourist Destination, Carnarvon Gorge, Queensland, Australia, 24 November 2019, Rock Art Network, www.bradshawfoundation.com.


Saturday, June 27, 2020

KEYHOLE SINK, KAIBAB NATIONAL FOREST, AZ. - ANOTHER RESTORATION:


Keyhole Sink, Kaibab National Forest. Photo Kaibab National Forest.


Keyhole Sink panel. Photo Kaibab National Forest.

A sad incident of vandalism occurred at Keyhole Sink, in Arizona's Kaibab national Forest occurred in August 2010. Some hero (or heroes) with a can of silvery-white paint added their work to a petroglyph panel. 


Keyhole Sink panel vandalized. Forest. Photo Kaibab National Forest. 

"Keyhole Sink is a canyon in the shape of a keyhole near Williams, Arizona. The canyon is best known for its petroglyphs, which were created about 1,000 years ago by the Cohonina people, and the seasonal waterfalls that flow into the canyon." (Wikipedia)


Restoration crew with wire brushes. Photo Kaibab National Forest.

In November, 2010, a team of National Forest personnel led by rock art restorer Johannes Loubser and Kaibab National Forest archaeologist Neil Weintraub performed a restoration on the panel. Several materials and techniques were tested before they decided on their final strategy.


Restoration crew with butane torch and Munsell chart. Photo Kaibab National Forest.

According to Weintraub "for thousands of years and for thousands of visitors - both recent and prehistoric - Keyhole Sink was a serene place to make a connection with nature and the past. I feel that all changed in late August when someone decided to hike in three-quarters of a mile to the petroglyph panel with a bucket of paint." (Banks 2010)


Restoration crew spraying Elephant Snot.
Photo Kaibab National Forest.

The process that they used to remove the paint involved both chemicals and heat. The paint used was an aluminum roofing cement and much of that could be removed from the background rock surface (not the petroglyphs proper) with butane torches. Within the lines of the petroglyphs the butane torches were used to heat "very fine steel brushes just enough to get the brush to help us peel back the paint." (Weintraub 2019)

Keyhole Sink panel after restoration restoration.
Photo Kaibab National Forest.

Remaining traces were removed with a biodegradable cleanser marketed under the name of Elephant Snot. "In 2013, we used our Youth Conservation Corps crew of local high school students to use 'Elephant Snot' to clean up the mess created by the vandals. It worked beautifully and visitors can no longer tell that the site was vandalized. 'Elephant Snot' is a biodegradable cleanser that works on certain paint materials better than others. We have had great success with it, especially in our volcanic landscape." (Weintraub 2019)

I am pleased to note another successful rock art restoration, as well as the materials and techniques used in this endeavor. Another marvelous job.

NOTE: The images in this posting were provided by the Kaibab National Forest. I wish to thank South Kaibab Zone archaeologist Neil Weintraub for his cooperation with RockArtBlog in providing this information, and for the good work of restoring this site. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.
NOTE: The weird effects in some type are the result of changes Blogger has made in their style and formatting. As they do not have an instruction manual it may take me some time to master these. Please bear with me. 

REFERENCES:

Banks, Jacqueline
2010 Vandalized Keyhole Sink Petroglyph Panel Receives Restoration Work, Kaibab National Forest News Release, November 19, 2010

Weintraub, Neil S.
2019 Personal Communication, December 6, 2019.

Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keyhole_Sink

Saturday, June 20, 2020

DATING AUSTRALIAN ROCK ART WITH MUD WASP NESTS:

Australian mud wasp, Sceliphron laetum.

And while we have been on the subject of rock art in Australia - mud daubers (wasps) have long been a friend to potters as a guide to good deposits of local clays they can use to produce their pottery, now they are becoming recognized as friends to Australian rock art researchers as a source of potential dating for rock art panels.

Not so much a new technique, but a new source of datable material has been found in rock art panels in Australia - mud wasp nests. Made from mud found locally by "mud dauber" wasps, the nests are assembled with cells for the incubation of the offspring, then filled with stung and paralyzed insects for food and a single egg by the female wasp. A mud wasp nest on top of a painted rock art panel will have to have been made after the rock art was created, and if paint is found on top of the remains of an earlier mud wasp nest that nest is older than the painting. If there are a number of nests, and they can be dated, the oldest date from on top of the paint will establish a minimum age range for the rock art (this could be true for petroglyphs as well). A range of maximum and minimum dates can be determined if there are nests found both over and under the painted image. If found in a protected location such as a rock shelter, a mud wasp nest can last a very long time indeed.

Gwion style rock art with mud wasp nest remnant. A) location, and B) close-up. Scinews.com

How can a mud wasp nest provide dating you ask? There are currently two possibilities; AMS 14C dating, and optically-stimulated luminescence (OSL). For AMS 14C dating small bits of organic matter in the dried mud are extracted and dated with an accelerator mass spectrometer (AMS), and the OSL dating is done on small grains of quartz sand included in the dried mud.

Photographig mud dauber nest on rock art, australianscience.tv

"OSL is a light sensitive signal that builds up over time during a period of 'burial' or cover. Provided the samples are not exposed to light during collection the signal can be stimulated in laboratory conditions and measured. When divided by the natural radioactivity of the soil or substrate, the amount of light (luminescence) produced is proportional to the period of burial time. OSL is the main method used for establishing chronologies for excavated occupation deposits that pre-date the maximum AMS 14C boundary, or in deposits that lack ample carbon samples. Samples of sediments found within the cave environment have no direct association with the art, but sediments may be collected by wasps and then 'buried' within mudwasp nests found on top of the art. Dating of mudwasp nests using OSL was first introduced by Roberts et al. They initially worked with large nests and sampled each layer to determine the extent to which light no longer penetrated the nests and the quartz was effectively 'buried' and supported their OSL age estimates with AMS 14C or organics found within two nests (Roberts et al)".

As mud dauber wasps are found pretty much all over the world this tool may provide valuable information in many instances where rock art is otherwise undatable.

NOTE: Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should read the original reports at the sites listed below.

REFERENCES:

Roberts RG, Walsh GL, Murray A, Olley J, Jones R, Morwood MJ, et al.

1997 Luminescence dating of rock art and past environments using mud-wasp nests in northern Australia, Nature, 1997; 387 (6634): 696-699.

Ross, June, Kira Westaway, Meg Travers, Michael J. Morwood, and John Hayward,

2016 Into the Past: A Step Towards a Robust Kimberley Rock Art Chronology, August 31, 2016, Plosone, https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0161726