Saturday, October 20, 2018
PALEOLITHIC STAR CHARTS - THE NORTHERN CROWN IN EL CASTILLO?
I continue
my exploration of (supposed) Paleolithic Star Charts with what has been called
a diagram of the Northern Crown constellation in El Castillo Cave, in Spain. El
Castillo is the current holder of the title for the oldest art in Europe with
recent dates for red painted elements; Red circle: 40,800 BP, Red Hand: 37,300
BP (David 2017:146) I wrote about these dates, the oldest currently known for
Europe, on September 20, 2014, in a column titled Uranium Isotope Dating Reveals Perhaps The Oldest Cave Art In Europe,
on RockArtBlog. (Faris 2014)
A
semicircle of dots on the right side of the Panel de las Manos has been
identified by Dr. Michael Rappenglueck as another
Paleolithic Star Chart, this one the Corona
Borealis, or Northern Crown. One of those who had taken him seriously;
Kathleen Flanagan Rollins, wrote in her blog Misfits and Heroes; "After
visiting El Castillo and looking at the panel in question, I have to admit I
was wrong. It's not a clear semi-circle of start but more like a full circle. I
suppose that's the danger of working from a diagram rather than the real
thing." (Rollins 2015) This does not seem to me to be an effective
argument against the idea of this painting as Corona Borealis as there are
plenty of other stars around the constellation that one can decide could be
included in the constellation to make it a rough, but full, circle. I will give this one to Rappenglueck; arc, or circle - I don't see that it matters.
My
objections to this theory are the same as my objections to Rappenglueck's other
identified Paleolithic Star Charts. We cannot know
whether Paleolithic peoples of Europe even recognized constellations or had the
concept of arrangements of stars representing shapes in the sky. Even if they
did they certainly would not have identified this grouping as a crown, the concept of a crown was doubtless millennia in mankind's future. Also, I still am not
convinced that the people would have gone deep underground to paint star charts
when all they had to do to see them was look up at night. I get the "secret
knowledge" argument, I just don't agree with it. I am not saying that this
theory is not possible, I am just saying that I do not see anywhere near enough
evidence to make such leaps to conclusions. I see too many possible arguments against, and too few arguments in favor.
NOTE:
Some images in this posting were retrieved from the internet with a search for
public domain photographs. If any of these images are not intended to be public
domain, I apologize, and will happily provide the picture credits if the owner
will contact me with them. For further information on these reports you should
read the originals at the sites listed below.
REFERENCES:
David,
Bruno
2017 Cave Art, Thames & Hudson, London.
Faris,
Peter,
2014 Uranium
Isotope Dating Reveals Perhaps The Oldest Cave Art In Europe, http://rockartblog.blogspot.com/2014/09/uranium-isotope-dating-reveals-perhaps.html
Rollins,
Kathleen Flanagan,
2015 El Castillo: Wonders and Questions, 12 September
2015, https://misfitsandheroes.wordpress.com/tag/northern-crown-in-rock-art/
Labels:
archaeoastronomy,
cave painting,
El Castillo,
rock art,
Spain,
stars
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
How the Crown looked like 40000 years ago? Stars are moving, constellations are changing. Halley discovered that stars are moving and he used 1600 years old Greek skycharts.
ReplyDelete