Spotted cat petroglyph, Farrington Springs,
Bent County, CO. Photo Peter Faris, 1990.
On May 1, 2009, I posted a column titled "A Spotted Cat
Petroglyph In Southeastern Colorado." In this I showed a petroglyph from
the marvelous rock art site of Farrington Springs and speculated as to exactly
what it represents. The petroglyph, of an animal covered with spots and with a
long tail and small ears appears to represent a cat, so then we ask ourselves
what kind of cat? The first guess of a spotted cat that might live in that
locale would be a young bobcat as they are covered with spots. Bobcats, however,
have short little stubby tails, and this cat has a long tail sticking out
behind him. Also, this animal is obviously not meant to represent a young
animal as it has the phallus of a fully grown male animal.
Little Rock's tipi, Southern Cheyenne, made 1904.
Buffalo Bill History Center, WY. Photo Peter Faris.
In that posting I wrote "So what kind of cat is this? Other examples of spotted cat
imagery can be located in Native American art. One that can be pointed to is
the image on the painted model tipi (above), owned by the Field Museum,
Chicago, which was collected in 1904 by Smithsonian ethnologist James Mooney
and was displayed at the Buffalo Bill Historical Center at Cody, Wyoming, when
the photograph above was taken. Another example I have seen is a carved stone
pipe shaped as a spotted cat, attributed to the Mississippian culture. That
carved stone pipe has been identified as an ocelot, which is one of the
possibilities for identity of the spotted cat. The closest report of an ocelot
sighting that I have been able to locate was somewhere along the Texas/Oklahoma
border which might fall within about 100 miles from the petroglyph site. The
other possibility for a long-tailed spotted cat is the jaguar, sightings of
which are still reported irregularly throughout the southwest. In either case (ocelot or jaguar),
they are now extinct through much of their former range in the southwest, and
even in prehistoric times were probably quite rare. This suggests that the
sighting of one of these animals was a significant event, worthy of reproducing
on your tipi, your pipe, or on the cliff." (Faris 2009)
Panther pipe, Hopewell, AD 1 - 400, Mann
Site, Posey County, Indiana, from Townsend,
2004, Hero, Hawk and Open Hand, p. 63.
Another source of comparative imagery can be found engraved
on a shell gorget which has been attributed to the Hopewell culture and is the
Missouri State Artifact. This so-called Jaguar Gorget was excavated from a
mound near Fairfield, Missouri, and is assigned to the Kansas City Hopewell
based upon associated artifactual evidence.
Jaguar gorget, Hopewell. From: Wood, 2000,
The Jaguar Gorget-"The Missouri State Artifact",
Missouri Archaeological Society Quarterly,
April-June 2000, 17(2):8-11.
"The identification of the image on the gorget as a jaguar, Felis onca,
seems secure. Only the slightly elongated body mars its realism. The
configuration of the body, the nature of the spots on the torso and underbelly,
the form of the head and ears, and the short tail all support this identity.
The only disharmonious features are on the creature's neck. Rather than being
spotted, the neck bears dots and dashes reminiscent of the ocelot, Felis pardalis,
although the neck on that species carries solid heavy lines.Both jaguars and
ocelots are native to tropical to subtropical and desert parts of Central
America, but their historical ranges extended into southern United States. The
jaguar once inhabited parts of southern California, most of Arizona, parts of
western and central New Mexico and, more to the point here, southeastern Texas
and southern Louisiana (Hall 1981:1037-39, Map 524). All of these locales are
far from southwestern Missouri, but we have no way of knowing the distribution
of the animal in the past." (Wood 2000)
This then
brings up the question of the time period during which jaguars
and ocelots roamed eastern North America coexisting with people.
"The
Pleistocene fossil record proves that jaguars once ranged over most of North
America. Jaguar fossils have been found as far northwest as Whitman
County, Washington and as far northeast as Port Kennedy, Pennsylvania.
Across the southeast jaguar fossils are among the most common of the large
carnivores found by fossil collectors. Along with dire wolves they were
probably a dominant predator in the region’s forests for most of the
Pleistocene, being more common than the infamous saber-tooth." (Gelbart 2010)
So, what is the most likely
identity of the spotted cat at Farrington Springs in southeastern Colorado?
Given indications that both ocelots and jaguars might (and I emphasize might)
have existed throughout much of North America in relic populations, and also
given that considerably larger numbers of ocelots and jaguars existed in Mexico
to stray or wander northward before the coming of the modern firearm, it
appears that the identification of this petroglyph as an ocelot or jaguar is
warranted.
REFERENCES:
Faris, Peter
2009 A Spotted Cat Petroglyph In Southeastern
Colorado, http://rockartblog.blogspot.com,
May 1, 2009.
Gelbart, Mark
2010 How Recently did the Jaguar (Panthera onca)
Roam Eastern North America, https://markgelbart.wordpress.com/2010/07/08/.
Townsend , Richard F., general editor, and Robert V. Sharp, editor,
2004 Hero, Hawk, and Open Hand: American Indian Art of the Ancient Midwest and South, Art Institute of Chicago and Yale University Press, New Haven and London.
Wood, W. Raymond
2000 The Jaguar Gorget-"The Missouri State
Artifact", Missouri
Archaeological Society Quarterly, April-June 2000, 17(2):8-11.
The Panther pipe, Hopewell, AD 1 - 400, Mann
ReplyDeleteSite, Posey County, is from INDIANA and not Illinois. Just incase anyone was interested