Saturday, March 25, 2017

THE MOAB MASTODON? A FISH-EATING BEAR REVISITED:




Moab Mastodon, Photograph
by Dell Crandall.

 On November 25, 2009, I wrote a column in RockArtBlog titled Elephantids In North American Rock Art - The Moab Mastodon, in which I expressed the opinion that this famous image, usually identified as the Moab Mastodon, is actually a bear eating a large fish.


Bear eating a salmon, National
Geographic, Vol. 209(2),
February 2006, photograph
Steve Winter.

In support of this suggestion I compared it to a photograph taken by Steve Winter for National Geographic Magazine of an Alaskan brown bear eating a salmon in virtually the same pose.

Bear eating a salmon,
carved antler, Lourdes,
France, redrawn from
Guthrie.

Another related example of the theme of a bear eating a fish found in Lourdes, France, was illustrated on page 218 in Dale Guthrie's excellent book The Nature of Paleolithic Art. A Paleolithic antler carving from Lourdes, France, shows a bear with a salmon in his mouth (Guthrie, p. 218).

Is this proof of anything, no it is not. It is circumstantial evidence only. While not bearing (really, a pun here?) directly on the question of the identification of the so-called Moab Mastodon, this carving at least helps establish that the theme of a bear eating a fish is one that had been illustrated by a primitive artist before, providing perspective on this claim for the identity of the Moab image.

REFERENCES:

Faris, Peter
2009 Elephantids In North American Rock Art, Nov. 25, 2009, https://rockartblog.blogspot.com.

Guthrie, R. Dale
2005    The Nature of Paleolithic Art, page 208, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Winter, Steve,
2006 National Geographic, Vol. 209, No. 2

No comments:

Post a Comment