Saturday, March 25, 2017


Moab Mastodon, Photograph
by Dell Crandall.

 On November 25, 2009, I wrote a column in RockArtBlog titled Elephantids In North American Rock Art - The Moab Mastodon, in which I expressed the opinion that this famous image, usually identified as the Moab Mastodon, is actually a bear eating a large fish.

Bear eating a salmon, National
Geographic, Vol. 209(2),
February 2006, photograph
Steve Winter.

In support of this suggestion I compared it to a photograph taken by Steve Winter for National Geographic Magazine of an Alaskan brown bear eating a salmon in virtually the same pose.

Bear eating a salmon,
carved antler, Lourdes,
France, redrawn from

Another related example of the theme of a bear eating a fish found in Lourdes, France, was illustrated on page 218 in Dale Guthrie's excellent book The Nature of Paleolithic Art. A Paleolithic antler carving from Lourdes, France, shows a bear with a salmon in his mouth (Guthrie, p. 218).

Is this proof of anything, no it is not. It is circumstantial evidence only. While not bearing (really, a pun here?) directly on the question of the identification of the so-called Moab Mastodon, this carving at least helps establish that the theme of a bear eating a fish is one that had been illustrated by a primitive artist before, providing perspective on this claim for the identity of the Moab image.


Faris, Peter
2009 Elephantids In North American Rock Art, Nov. 25, 2009,

Guthrie, R. Dale
2005    The Nature of Paleolithic Art, page 208, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Winter, Steve,
2006 National Geographic, Vol. 209, No. 2

No comments:

Post a Comment